The degree of allowable force used in the war must be measured against the force required to correct the just cause and limited by just intention see jus ad bellum. The wellknown indian thinker of the twentieth century sri aurobindo described the general nature of war in this way. Myers it is generally accepted that the revival of american interest in the traditional concept of the just war began sometime during the undeclared war in vietnam. His initial writings would later become the foundation of just war theory, a doctrine with numerous defendants and discreditors throughout the history of european thought. Click download or read online button to get just or unjust war book now. According to contemporary just war theory, a war is just only if it meets the six conditions presented in the following debate. However, some preference will be given to papers that consider the ethical implications of new, emerging, and future military technology and the resulting changing nature of warfare. Is there anything ethical america can do in syria now.
Aristotle, cicero, augustine, aquinas, and hugo grotius are among the philosophers who have espoused some form of a just war philosophy. It is then often noted that the consensus on this point is currently being challenged by those who claim that the prevention of large. As i will make clear below, i mean by a just war something more than merely a morally justified war. Augustine commented on the morality of war from a christian perspective, as did several arabic commentators from the 9th to the 12th centuries. Just war theory internet encyclopedia of philosophy. The project of just war theory has enjoyed a long and distinguished pedigree, dating back to the ancient grecoroman philosophy. The president was invoking the tenets of just war theory, a longstanding ethical tradition studied by theologians, heads of state, philosophers and military leaders alike, dealing with how and why. Thomas aquinas 12251274 codified augustines reflections into the distinct criteria that remain the basis of just war theory as it. Proportionality the proportionality of the use of force in a war. The paradigm of just war, she writes, is the bombing of afghanistan just war against terror, pp. Just war theory jus bellum justum is a doctrine, also referred to as a tradition, of military ethics studied by military leaders, theologians, ethicists and policy makers.
Discrimination the combatants discriminate between combatants and noncombatants. One common just war theory evaluation of war is that war is only justified if 1. The paper is highly useful to anyone runningor running against just war theory in the present resolution. The just war tradition or just war theory is one subset of military ethics. Secular philosophers and theologians gradually developed just war theory over the course of hundreds of yearswhen there were no nuclear weapons, when combatants could often assume symmetry, and when the catholic. Over 33 years ago, i was honorably discharged from the u. Although it was extensively developed by christian theologians, it. Modern writers of jwt have become just as important as the early developers. The purpose of the doctrine is to ensure war is morally justifiable through a series of criteria, all of which must be met for a war to be considered just. Pacifism is often located on a continuum for assessing the morality of war that includes realism, just war theory, and pacifism. We think of democracy as a greek invention, a western idea, but confucius wrote. Challenging the just war theory national catholic reporter.
Throughout the seminar, it continued to strike me that just war theory in and of itself is a mistaken concept. Augustine 354430 provides a foundation for just war theory in western literature. These criteria have been revised and expanded, notably by thomas aquinas in the th century. The paper is highly useful to anyone runningor running againstjust war theory in. As kant himself noted, rulers frequently cited grotius, pufendorf, and other justwar philosophers to justify their decisions to wage war, but rarely if ever were these philosophers cited to justify abstaining from war. In spite of the many studies that have appeared concerning war. Just war theory is a useful structure within which the discourse of war may be ethically examined. Religious authorization of war around the year 400 augustine published a polemical work against faus.
More resources on the criteria and case studies of just war theory are available at the just war theory website see resources at the left. In the stanford encyclopedia of philosophy, professor brian. If america is not prepared to supply the means necessary to achieve a just end, then the probability of success is in greater jeopardy than if we had never decided to. The task of just war theory is to seek a middle path between them. Over the centuries, it has, however, commanded a substantial influence from christianity, enlightenment philosophy, and western secular academia. The just war theory the just war theory is and interesting one simply because the phrase just war is an oxymoron. A summary of just war theory as it applies to declaring war. Apr, 2018 the usual framework philosophers would use to answer this questionthe socalled justwar theoryisnt providing clear answers. Rethinking the just war, part 1 the new york times. So either just war theory is outdated or terrorism is not war. Just war theory has a long history in the western intellectual tradition. A few, such as rousseau, argue for insurrection against oppressive rule.
We distinguish war from violent organized crime by the political objectives of combatants in war. In the evolving context of modern warfare, a moral calculus of war will require the philosopher of war to account not only for military personnel and civilians, but also for justifiable targets, strategies, and use of weapons. The just war theory specifies conditions for judging if it is just to go to war, and conditions for how the war should be fought. The modern secularization of just war theory and its lessons for. But just war was a worldly theory, in every sense of that term, and it continued to serve worldly interests against christian radicalism. Just or unjust war download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. Articles just war theory power that saves us both from that moral excess and that political folly. The history of the just war theory of the wisconsin.
Thomas aquinas provided the most celebrated and still discussed the main outlines of just war theory. He argues against kant scholars brian orend and susan shell, who claim that kant endorsed a modified just war theory. Although the speech was made officially to congress, how did fdr make it clear that he is speaking to and for the american people themselves. The history of just war theory begins in the works of some important philosophers. This is a body of thought that seeks to provide guidelines for when it is justified for one nation to wage war on another. It does, however, derive from the fact that the wars in vietnam, the persian gulf, yugoslavia, and the middle east provoked a resurgence of work in just war theory by philosophers trained in the analytic tradition. Notwithstanding the jus ad bellum criteria of last resort, just war theory seems to accept the inevitability of conflicts turning into wars. The real challenge to just war theory comes from pacifism. Just war theory acts therefore as a series of moral criteria to regulate the resort to warfare in order to prevent, rather than exacerbate, war for wars sake. Augustine is noted in history as the founder of just war theory in the western tradition the islamic world has its own tradition of just war theory based on the koran.
Find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. The just war tradition has enjoyed a long and distinguished pedigree, including such notables as augustine, aquinas, grotius, suarez, vattel and vitoria. In the first six of the books seven chapters, williams briefly explains kants views about philosophy and international law, and discusses in detail kants views about war. It seems to be making war safer rather than making it disappear.
Introduction to western philosophy the ethics of war and. The theory of the just war deals with the justification of the war jus ad bellum and how it must be fought jus in bello to respect the moral principles which govern our individual or. Just war theory has become a popular topic in international relations, political science, philosophy, ethics, and military history courses. Jul 21, 2014 the just war tradition or just war theory is one subset of military ethics. Introduction to western philosophy the ethics of war and peace1. The just war tradition may also consider the thoughts of various philosophers and lawyers through. It was from their meeting, eusebius tells us, that they agree to. Just war theory and consequentialism in a new paper, thomas hurka of the university of toronto discusses how just war theory considers consequences, but in a deontological framework. Nov 05, 2019 the foundational writings of just war theory from the early western developers are so astute, that it has become merely impossible for modern contributors of just war theory to ignore and neither should be ignored. This principle of independence has often been questioned by moral philosophers.
The theorys first principle is that if youre going to go. The triumph of just war theory and the dangers of success. Terrorists use the methods of violent organized crime and have political aims. The justification can be either theoretical or historical. The just war tradition also considers the writings of various philosophers and lawyers through history, and examines both their philosophical visions of. Although realism undoubtedly has its adherents, few philosophers find it compelling. The just war tradition, then, also grapples with the historical body of rules or. The first is from an encyclopedia of war and ethics and the second is an online source from the stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. I put forward a number of arguments against these views. The issue in the natural law tradition is whether or not those who have committed capital crimes and are now in prison present enough of a threat to the lives of others to permit their execution under an expanded principle of self defense.
Assuming that the declaration of war against japan meets the criteria posited by just war theory, was it therefore traitorous to refuse to fight in it. Just war theory just war theory and the war on terrorism chase whaley theology 225 global issues professor corey harris may 3th 2017 1 just war theory throughout time christians have been involved in wars and gradually overtime philosophers began to explain how christians are able to act on war under certain circumstances. Just war theory is probably the most influential perspective on the ethics of war and peace. The theoretical aspect is concerned with ethically justifying war and the forms that warfare may or may not take. Philosophers, ethicists and theologians have long wrestled with the. Kants just war theory 3z5 reflects on the contributions of traditional just war theorists and arrives at the following judgment. Some people argue that the just war doctrine is inherently immoral, while others suggest that there is no place for ethics in. The second reason for the decline in allegiance to the theory is largely independent of changes in the practice of war. Classic just war theory does not recognize terrorists as legitimate combatants.
Plato once said wonder is the feeling of the philosopher, and philosophy begins in wonder. Thomas aquinas provided the most celebrated and still discussed the main outlines of just war theory just war theory traditionally has two sets of criteria. Nov 30, 2015 the president was invoking the tenets of just war theory, a longstanding ethical tradition studied by theologians, heads of state, philosophers and military leaders alike, dealing with how and why. The theory of just war began in the service of the powers. As a result, the tradition evolved into a myriad of separate branches, which differ in their substantive contents, yet use. Cosmopolitanism, just war theory and legitimate authority. For help on earlier versions of this article, i am also grateful to audiences at philosophy colloquia at city university graduate center, oxford university. The greeks talked about war and they talked about it in terms of right and wrong. He espoused significant principles of ethics and politics, in a time when the greeks were espousing the same things. Theory, but war,1 begins with two chapters on the thought of sixteenthcentury thinkers. Biblical references are to the king james version available in an online pdf version at. Pdf political philosophers on war arguments inside the. Finally, critics of the just war tradition often suggest that the theory is fundamentally wrongheaded.
A special part of the interest of just war theory is that it is built on a long and rich historical development, just as a special part of the interest of the just war tradition is that it is the history. For further information, check out hurkas the consequences of war, which goes into more depth. Just war theory a historically significant part of scholastic philosophy and political theory addressing the boundaries for a morally acceptable use of military force. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Indeed, there is an ongoing debate about the proper relation between just war theory and pacifism that focuses on the question of whether the just war theory begins with a pacifist presumption against war. A critique of just war theory, howard williams new york. Any paper on any topic related to the ethics of war, just war theory, the moral implications for the future of warfare, or related issues will be considered. With this wonder a philosopher expresses his thoughts sometimes making life easier for millions. Famous philosophers list of world famous philosophers. Jan 31, 2008 in all three respects the resulting theory assesses consequences in a deontological way. Justice and the justification of war in ancient greece. Pope francis takes on just war theory consortiumnews. That is, in standard just war theory, a distinction is drawn between jus ad bellumwhether the war is, in principle, justifiedand jus in bellowhether the means used to carry it out are justified.
Just war theory deals with the justification of how and why wars are fought. Jul 20, 2006 the just war theory specifies conditions for judging if it is just to go to war, and conditions for how the war should be fought. From cicero to st augustine, thomas aquinas to hugo grotius, philosophers and theologians have proposed numerous criteria for determining if a war is just. Quizlet flashcards, activities and games help you improve your grades. Thomas aquinas 12251274 codified augustines reflections into the distinct criteria that remain the basis of just war theory as it is used today. The most respected contemporary articulation of just war tradition is, undoubtedly, michael walzers just and unjust wars.
Well, another recent and also highly regarded inquiry into just war theory is by moralpolitical philosopher, jean bethke elshtain. Against the theory of the just war against the theory of the just war. A comprehensive directory of world famous philosophers, including their biography, philosophies and work. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want.
President roosevelts declaration of war officially titled the joint address to congress leading to a declaration of war against japan 1941 distribute the following definition of just war theory. Firstly, it is important to establish what just war theory is and what it says. Nuclear deterrence a strategy of nations possessing significant nuclear arsenals for deterring military actions, particularly the initiation of nuclear war, on the part of other. Military hegemony versus just military preparedness, in philosophy after hiroshima, ed. War is defined by the merriamwebster dictionary as a state of usually open and declared armed. That is, just war theory should be universal, binding on all and capable in turn of appraising the. The pope is hardly the first to raise the issue of war and peace in human life. It is therefore to be wondered at that the word right has not been completely banished from military politics as superfluous pedantry, and that no state has been bold enough.
It recognizes the war is hell mentality and is, if anything, born from it, encouraging a resort to force only in cases where diplomacy is unable to function. Today i had a seminar on just war theory, the theory of when it is justifiable for one state to go to war with another. In my own writings, i have argued that just war theory needs to be supplemented by criteria of just military preparedness jus ante bellum. But some have a long life in this world, a history most often of service to the powersthatbe, but also, sometimes, an oppositionist history. Introduction to western philosophy the ethics of war and peace1 here a couple of summaries of just war theory. It is impor tant to note, though, that christian radicalism had more than one social research, vol. Just war theory and its application study guide by halaranda includes questions covering vocabulary, terms and more. Just war theory serves to justify or to condemnhow, why and by whose authority wars are conducted. Gobbs noted the universal nature of war as well when he stated that everybody wages war against everybody. His comment suggests that there is an almost universal aspect to just war theory and that while there is a european just war tradition, a just war theory could be constructed for other societies. A case in point, larry mays recent edited collection, entitled not just war. A bibliographical essay on just war theory doctrines of god.
As kant himself noted, rulers frequently cited grotius, pufendorf, and other just war philosophers to justify their decisions to wage war, but rarely if ever were these philosophers cited to justify abstaining from war. Many scholars interested in war continue to frame their arguments in the terms of. Human rights and military intervention, paul robinson, ed. Conference proceedings are regularly published, offering readers a breadth of issues that the topic stirs. The philosophical ideal of world citizenship, pauline kleingeld new york. The questions of pacifism, the just war theory, and war itself are very personal for me. More recently, profound challenges to traditional just war theoryunder the banner of revisionismhave. With alberico gentili and hugo grotius just war theory was replaced by international law theory, codified as a set of rules, which today still encompass the points commonly debated, with some modifications. The philosophy of war internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Although perpetual peace was a moral ideal for kant, he did not regard it as an unattainable goal. Over time, philosophers have divided just war thinking into two parts, jus ad. Laurie calhoun focuses on the views and arguments expressed by political philosophers on and against war theory.
670 452 28 31 972 389 589 1501 637 907 146 118 901 415 268 1213 46 878 441 694 1310 755 1438 1473 94 1274 1250 935 1189 539 1334 1053 314 773 499 213 404